Ask Judith: Submission #12

Submission Number: 12
Submission ID: 96
Submission UUID: 31942ba5-9d92-4614-9524-0156dbf3772c
Submission URI: /web/ask-judith

Created: Fri, 09/24/2021 - 02:57 AM
Completed: Fri, 09/24/2021 - 02:57 AM
Changed: Tue, 12/26/2023 - 12:58 PM

Remote IP address: 49.195.62.113
Submitted by: Anonymous
Language: English

Is draft: No
Webform: Ask Judith
Submitted to: Ask Judith
Walter Lee
Thank you so much Judith for this opportunity to ask you questions.

On page 135 of Directing Actors, you write, "Emotional events for characters can be wins or losses, discoveries, choices or mistakes - not realisations or reactions, which are not playable."

Can you please help me understand why "realisations or reactions" are not playable?

I would have thought that a reaction is playable?

For example, the character reacts to the other character pushing her or telling her their mother has died, for example.
Hello Walter! Thank you for your question. I agree that the sentence you are quoting -- from the original edition of Directing Actors, which was published in 1996 -- was unclear. Over the years, the subject of "emotional event" has been the one I get the most questions about. And there isn't one quick answer! That's one of the main reasons why I wrote the 25th Anniversary Edition, which came out in April 2021. There are revisions to the whole book, but especially the chapters on Tools/Choices, Emotional Event, Script Analysis, and Rehearsal. Plus a new chapter added about Directing Children. I believe Emotional Event is the most important tool of the director, so I put a major effort into approaching the topic from as many different angles as I could, using many new examples. Best wishes, Judith
Yes

  • “I am eternally grateful for your help.”

    TAIKA WAITITI, writer-director, JOJO RABBIT, THOR RAGNAROK, HUNT FOR THE WILDERPEOPLE, WHAT WE DO IN THE SHADOWS, BOY, EAGLE VS SHARK, FLIGHT OF THE CONCHORDS

  • “I took a seminar with an acting teacher named Judith Weston. I learned a key insight to character. She believed that all well-drawn characters have a spine, and the idea is that the character has an inner motor, a dominant, unconscious goal that they’re striving for, an itch that they can’t scratch. I took to this like a duck to water.”

    ANDREW STANTON [from his Feb 2012 TED Talk] writer-director, FINDING DORY, WALL-E, FINDING NEMO, A BUG’S LIFE; director, BETTER CALL SAUL, STRANGER THINGS; writer, TOY STORY, TOY STORY 2, TOY STORY 3

  • "Judith's method is wonderful because it is practical. She has given me numerous tools to solve problems on the set and to earn the trust of actors. Her classes and her book are invaluable resources to any director."

    LAWRENCE TRILLING, director, GOLIATH, RECTIFY, PARENTHOOD, MASTERS OF SEX, PUSHING DAISIES, DAMAGES, BROTHERS AND SISTERS, NIP/TUCK, MONK, SCRUBS, INVASION, ALIAS, FELICITY

  • "Thank you for teaching me how to direct actors. Taking your classes made me believe I could direct. Taking your classes gave me a base, a foundation, a framework to find my own style. To step out on faith. I'm forever grateful. Love and respect to you, magnificent Judith Weston." 

    AVA DuVERNAY, director, WHEN THEY SEE US, QUEEN SUGAR, A WRINKLE IN TIME, SELMA, SCANDAL, MIDDLE OF NOWHERE

  • "Everything you taught me was more than useful. I am deeply grateful."

    ALEJANDRO GONZÁLEZ IÑÁRRITU, director, THE REVENANT, BIRDMAN, BIUTIFUL, BABEL, 21 GRAMS, AMORES PERROS